The
so-called "Walt Disney" version of the film is missing a
few key elements from the original film, including a love triangle that
would have made the film a heck of a lot more interesting. Instead of
a racy look at one of America's decadent nightspots, the movie is a rather
bland and average drama that takes place in a sanitized version of Studio
54.
Shane O'Shea (Ryan Phillipe) dreams of hanging out with the stars at Studio
54 instead of bumming around with his friends at New Jersey bars. So, he
gets his friends to drive over to New York City to attempt to get in to
the notoriously hard-to-get-into disco. Shane is spotted by Studio 54 owner
Steve Rubell (Mike Myers), who lets him (but not his friends) into the
disco.
Shane eventually gets a job at Studio 54 and strikes up a friendship with
Greg (Breckin Meyer) and Anita (Salma Hayek), both of whom work at the
bar as a busboy and a coat room clerk respectively. Greg shows Shane the
ropes as a busboy, and explains the rules of working in as strange an atmosphere
as the disco party capital of the world.
The rest of the plot deals with Shane trying
to pit his naivete against the "shocking" world of Studio 54,
succeeding in making a name for himself amongst the odd clientele of
the club. Frankly,
I don't think
that the story of the fictional Shane is anywhere near as interesting
as a bio-pic on Steve Rubell could have been. If a filmmaker prefers
to focus
on a fictional character, they should at least make him or her interesting
enough to carry an audience's interest throughout the running time of
the film. Shane O'Shea is no Dirk Diggler.
Mike Myers does an adequate job of portraying
Steve Rubell as a complicated and somewhat fragile character. His performance
isn't
quite as "Oscar-worthy" as
some reviewers have supposedly coined it, but it's not bad. It's nowhere
near as yawn-inducing as Ryan Phillipe's Shane or as under-utilized as
Salma Hayek's Anita either.
It's a shame that this story couldn't have been told as it was intended,
because I believe there was a killer movie here originally. It's a sure
sign that too many cooks spoil the broth when there are almost as many
producers' names in the credits as there are cast members'.